A federal judge has acquitted MIT-educated brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno in the case over a $25 million Ethereum exploit executed in approximately 12 seconds. Cointelegraph reported the outcome on November 17, citing Reuters. The November 16 court order identifies the prosecution's decisive failure: prosecutors did not prove that the brothers made material misrepresentations while executing their scheme.
The judge's finding concerned the evidence needed for wire fraud and related convictions, rather than a general declaration that exploiting cryptocurrency software is lawful.
For crypto enforcement in the United States, the case exposes a specific problem: describing an adversarial trading strategy and its losses does not, by itself, establish the alleged fraud.
A failed prosecution after a deadlocked jury
US District Judge Jessica Clarke entered the judgment of acquittal after an earlier trial ended without a unanimous verdict. The Block reports that the jury deadlocked in November 2025.
The earlier mistrial left the charges unresolved. The latest ruling grants the brothers' motion for acquittal after examining whether the trial evidence could support convictions.
According to The Block's account, the brothers used bait transactions to attract sandwich trading bots before intercepting their trades. Clarke distinguished the question of whether that strategy was improper or unethical from whether prosecutors had established criminal wire fraud under the statutes they invoked.
The financial result supplied the arresting headline: approximately $25 million changed hands within seconds. The prosecution still needed to connect the conduct to the charged offense. The court found that connection missing at the material misrepresentation step.
The outcome differs from the guilty plea in the Hyperliquid listing trades case. Crypto trading cases turn on the conduct alleged and the evidence supporting each charge; the presence of automated trading does not mean they will reach the same legal result.
Transaction ordering turned against its usual beneficiaries
The court's account explains the economic tension behind the exploit. The targeted traders used sandwich strategies, placing transactions around another user's trade to profit from the resulting price movement.
Their expected profit depended on execution order.
The brothers' code, called Omakase, attracted those bots with lure transactions. A software vulnerability then allowed access to transaction information the traders expected to remain private. Replacement transactions disrupted the intended sequence, leaving the targeted traders with losses and generating profits for the brothers.
The opinion describes MEV-Boost as software that separates specialized block building from a validator's task of proposing a block. Relays move proposed blocks between those participants, initially withholding their transaction contents from the validator.
That arrangement helps explain how the dispute differs from an ordinary wallet theft. The contested activity involved access to pending transactions and the sequence in which trades would execute. The traders committed capital expecting a particular sequence to produce a return. Omakase disrupted that expectation.
The operational lesson is specific: a profitable trading strategy can depend on assumptions about another participant's behavior. When those assumptions fail, traders can lose money even as the trading system continues processing transactions.
The original allegations reached beyond twelve seconds
The Justice Department announced the original charges in May 2024, accusing the brothers of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering.
Its account alleged months of preparation before the brief execution window. Prosecutors said the brothers studied the targeted traders' behavior, established shell companies and used multiple cryptocurrency addresses and foreign exchanges. They also alleged that subsequent transfers concealed the source and ownership of the proceeds.
Reading the original announcement beside the acquittal ruling explains the distance between an investigative narrative and a conviction. Prosecutors presented preparation, execution and subsequent fund movements as parts of a planned criminal scheme. The court nevertheless required proof of the representations necessary to sustain the fraud theory.
For readers assessing future exploit cases, the useful distinction is between evidence that someone deliberately pursued a financial result and evidence satisfying the particular offense charged. Technical complexity and a large payout can make a case newsworthy while leaving that second question contested.
Overview
Anton and James Peraire-Bueno have been acquitted in the prosecution over a $25 million Ethereum exploit carried out in approximately 12 seconds. The case had previously ended in a jury deadlock.
The November 16 ruling rests on prosecutors' failure to prove material misrepresentations. The resulting judgment acquits both brothers.



