Tether has invoked "The Big Short" to challenge S&P Global Ratings after the agency kept USDT at its weakest stablecoin stability assessment. Cointelegraph reported the response on November 19, 2026, following S&P's November 18 review, which put higher-risk holdings at the equivalent of 28% of circulating USDT as of September 30.
The assessment remained 5, or "weak," unchanged from November 2025. The latest development is a renewed dispute over reserve risk, rather than another downgrade. For users holding dollar stablecoins, the substantive issue is the relationship between assets exposed to losses and the surplus available to absorb them.
The 28% figure measures exposure against outstanding tokens
According to Cointelegraph's reporting on the assessment, S&P's higher-risk category includes gold, Bitcoin, public equities, secured loans and corporate bonds. Those holdings were equivalent to 28% of USDT in circulation at September's end, compared with 24% a year earlier.
The denominator is circulating tokens; describing the figure as 28% of total reserves changes the measurement.
The increase amounts to four percentage points. Exposure to the assets S&P considers riskier grew relative to outstanding USDT, even while the final assessment stayed unchanged.
S&P warned that a substantial decline in those assets could leave USDT undercollateralized. Its concern is a potential shortfall arising if reserves lose value before an equivalent amount of token liabilities disappears.
The category also combines different risks. Gold and Bitcoin can change in market value, while loans introduce questions about repayment. Treating the whole bucket as a single position would obscure the separate ways losses could arise.
Tether's reserve cushion gives the argument a numerical test
Tether's October 30 reserve announcement supplies the other side of that calculation. For September 30, 2026, the company reported approximately $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in liabilities, including $183.47 billion related to issued digital tokens.
The resulting surplus was $7.95 billion. Tether said its buffer had increased from roughly $4.1 billion at the end of June.
Using those reported figures, excess assets were approximately 4.3% of total liabilities. That calculation helps explain the disagreement: a growing surplus can coexist with a growing allocation to assets exposed to losses. Either number alone gives an incomplete picture.
An illustrative stress calculation makes the proportions easier to assess. Applying the reported 28% exposure to September's token liabilities produces a higher-risk bucket of roughly $51 billion. A uniform decline of about 15.5% across that bucket would roughly equal the reported $7.95 billion surplus, assuming everything else stayed unchanged.
The calculation illustrates the scale of losses the published cushion could absorb under that simplified assumption. It is not a forecast: the assets would not necessarily fall together, and earnings or changes elsewhere in the reserves would alter the result.
Tether also reported $132.4 billion in direct and indirect Treasury-bill holdings. Its reserve position therefore includes a substantial pool of government debt alongside the holdings under dispute.
A film reference challenges the assessor, not the calculation
Tether's reference to "The Big Short" attacks S&P's credibility. It gives the response an immediately recognizable frame, but the argument about USDT still depends on the present reserve portfolio.
S&P's published methodology begins with asset quality, including credit, market-value and custody risks. It then considers protections such as overcollateralization, followed by factors including governance and redeemability. Its five-point stability scale runs from 1, "very strong," to 5, "weak."
Under that framework, reserve size and reserve quality answer different questions. A surplus measures the distance between reported assets and liabilities on a particular date. An assessment of asset quality considers the ways that distance might shrink.
For a holder, control over the token and control over its backing are also separate. Moving USDT into a wallet under the user's control changes who holds the keys while leaving the issuer's reserve composition unchanged. Holders who treat a stablecoin balance as available dollars remain exposed to that reserve risk.
The practical tension in this review is specific: Tether reported a larger loss buffer, while S&P identified greater relative exposure to higher-risk assets.
Overview
S&P retained USDT's lowest stability assessment as higher-risk holdings reached the equivalent of 28% of circulating tokens. Tether challenged the agency with a reference to "The Big Short."
The reported reserve surplus provides a financial counterweight to S&P's concern, although its capacity depends on the losses it must absorb. At September 30, Tether reported $191.45 billion in assets, $183.50 billion in liabilities and a $7.95 billion surplus.



